About This Blog

Moms Speak Up is collaborative blog of writers from various backgrounds. We're talking about the environment, dangerous imports, health care, food safety, media and marketing, education, politics and many other hot topics of concern.

About Us

We are women, parents, consumers, voters and much, much more and we're fed up with the "business as usual" attitude of politicians & greedy corporations. It's time for us to speak up and be heard!

Kicking the Bottled Water Habit

With the crazy hot weather, staying hydrated is really important and water is certainly a better choice than soda. And yes, we’re supposed to drink 8+ glasses of water a day, which I do. But I have to say the plastic bottle thing has got to stop.

Everywhere I go people are carrying their Dasani and Aquafina but have you ever thought about where all those bottles go when people are done with the water? A small percentage get recycled but mostly, they end up in landfills; tons and tons and tons of them. That in itself is inexcusable. Is that what we want to leave for our children and grandchildren? A world filled with toxic plastic leftovers?

There is, however, another reason to consider kicking the bottled water habit… Carcinogenic and (cancer-causing) and endocrine-disrupting chemicals can leach into the water and then we drink it. The risk of ingesting those chemicals goes up dramatically if you re-use plastic water bottles, put them in the dishwasher etc.

Adding insult to injury, bottles meant to be re-used, like Nalgene Lexan polycarbonate bottles (#7 on the bottom) have been shown to leach BPA’s (bisphenol A).

Recent research has linked the chemical to a variety of disorders, including obesity and breast cancer, and one chilling 2007 study, published in the journal PLoS Genetics, found that BPA exposure can cross generations. Pregnant mice exposed to low levels of BPA led to chromosomal abnormalities, which possibly cause birth defects and miscarriages, in grandchildren. Source

Crossing generations? *shudder*

If you have a strong preference for the reusable Nalgene bottles, they do make safer (supposedly safer…I personally don’t really believe it) alternatives made from #2 high density polyethylene (HDPE). But…the safest and most environmentally friendly option is to skip plastic containers altogether.

You can now get glass baby bottles which are safer and far superior to plastic in every way (other than being breakable, of course) and you can get sippy cups by SIGG in cool metal bottles that leach nothing dangerous into your children’s drinks. (ed. note: SIGG metal reusable bottles do have a water-based liner that is reputedly safe but I just read that if the liner is damaged, leaching can occur. Just an FYI)

Similar to the SIGG bottles are many different varieties of reusable metal bottles (unlined) by a plethora of companies. They’re a bit more expensive but imagine how much money you’d save if you didn’t buy all those plastic bottles of water which are almost always from municipal water sources anyway. AKA TAP WATER!

When I think of it like that, the $14.99 I shelled out for a reusable metal kids bottle for my daughter doesn’t sting nearly as much and I can relax a little knowing she’s not getting slowly poisoned.

add to sk*rt

Related Posts



  1. Catherine said:

    I definetly feel trapped in the water bottle limbo. Yes, toss-away water bottles = bad. But as you say, pretty much all “permanent” water bottles have BPA. And, I know metal cans of food also have BPA - would metal water bottles be different? What’s a thirsty person-on-the-go to do??

  2. Izzy said:

    I think the BPA in food cans comes from a liner that the reusable metal bottles don’t have. Check out the ones I linked to. They’re all BPA and chemical safe.

  3. Amanda said:

    Great post, Izzy!

    Catherine, you bring up a good point. Cheap metal water bottles may contain a liner that leaches BPA. Sigg aluminum water bottles are lined, but the company says the lining doesn’t leach at all. They’ve been quiet about whether or not the lining contains BPA. Klean Kanteen water bottles are stainless steel and not lined at all. We did a post on the subject at Enviroblog this spring (sorry for the messy link): http://www.enviroblog.org/2007/05/ask_ewg_i_am_looking_for_a_saf.htm

  4. Izzy said:

    SIGG says their bottle’s lining is water-based but I just read that if the lining is damaged, you’re no longer protected from leaching. That said, I’m going to remove the link.

  5. Dee said:

    The leaching from aluminum bottles is not necessarily BPA (unless the liner has BPA)… it’s aluminum.

    Leaching that can occur in aluminum bottles if something acidic like apple juice is in put in them, hence the reason Sigg added a non-toxic lining. You can only put water (maybe milk??) in the unlined Kleen Kanteen bottles or they can leach aluminum.

    Been doing a ton of research on aluminum drinking bottles and the new plastic alternatives.

    That said, my little one likes a little juice mixed with her water, so I plan to go with a Sigg bottle for her.

    Take a look at this testing info on Sigg bottles for more info. http://www.progressivekid.com/shop/OKO-Test%20on%20Water%20Bottles.aspx

    Hope more info helps!

  6. Mark said:

    Just wondering… any evidence to indicate whether it would be better to go stainless steel, or with the aluminium bottle. Trying to decide what to buy for my child. Thanks for the great info. Sure makes you think. It scares me to think the alumium could be a threat if the lining is damaged. Plastic is sure proven to be a danger to our children as well as our enviroment!



Leave a Comment




Brighter Planet's 350 Challenge



The 2008 Mothers Acting Up
Handbook is now available!


Safer Toy Guide 2007




Copyright 2007 • Moms Speak Up • All Rights Reserved