About This Blog

Moms Speak Up is collaborative blog of writers from various backgrounds. We're talking about the environment, dangerous imports, health care, food safety, media and marketing, education, politics and many other hot topics of concern.

About Us

We are women, parents, consumers, voters and much, much more and we're fed up with the "business as usual" attitude of politicians & greedy corporations. It's time for us to speak up and be heard!

What’s So Complicated About Universal Health Care?

I read a few years ago that health insurer Kaiser-Permanante’s CEO got a $20 million dollar bonus that year in addition to his exorbitant salary. TWENTY. MILLION. DOLLARS. In healthcare, bonus’ like that come when the company has been extremely profitable and the way they do that is to raise premiums, deny care and lowball doctors on their negotiated fees. It’s a nasty, nasty business.

Okay, so imagine if a company covered it’s overhead but never overcharged, denied or lowballed. Imagine if that $20 million dollars had stayed in the pockets of their insured. Imagine that people actually had good health insurance that they could actually afford.

I don’t understand why such a thing can only be imaginary. I don’t understand why there cannot be non-profit health insurance agencies, kind of like credit unions, where profit is not a motivating factor and savings are passed on to their customers. Where the agency and the insured work as partners in care instead of having an adversarial relationship, as is the norm with profit-driven companies.

People would pay their “premium” out of their paychecks like most already do for Medicare and and their health insurance except 1) they wouldn’t have to pay that Medicare tax because Medicare would be dismantled and 2) They would pay on a sliding scale based on their paycheck, just like the Medicare tax. 3) Exorbitant premiums would be a thing of the past. No more $800-1000 a month for a family of three, no more outrageous deductibles that you’ll never meet unless you’re stricken with a horrible, catastrophic illness.

This system would be far more efficient than Medicare because it would still be run as a business by non-profit contractors who would bid on the contract and whose contracts would be renewed contingent on their service and efficiency levels, pretty much like any other contractor in the private sector. The government would effectively be out of the healthcare business and healthcare would be run like a non-profit by people who are actually experienced in running businesses.

There is NO reason this couldn’t work and there is no reason it wouldn’t be totally superior to our currently broken systems of Medicare and private healthcare. When you remove the profit factor, which totally degrades healthcare, and focus on serving customers and fairly compensating doctors, people will finally get the care they need.

add to kirtsy

Related Posts



  1. SciFi Dad said:

    What if health care funding came from taxation? An increase in income tax would cover your sliding scale for end-user subsidizing, and the remainder would come from corporate and other taxes.

    Here in Ontario, we don’t have an OHIP (Ontario Health Insurance Program) charge on our pay stub; it’s just part of the provincial tax we pay.

  2. forHealth said:

    Many of Blue Cross and Shields are already technically not for profit. They don’t behave that way though and their upper echelons receive similar bonus to Kaiser.

  3. Julie Pippert said:

    Good point!

    How can other places manage it…and don’t tell me it’s because they compromise care (not that YOU would, just general you). Other countries’ residents with health care seem generally fine, although everything has room for improvement. And we already seriously compromise our health care here.

  4. Sarah said:

    I would love Universal health care.

  5. Izzy said:

    to forHealth:

    I don’t understand how companies that have shareholders can be not-for-profit. They’re pretty much required to be profitable or their stock plummets.

    Speaking of Blue Cross Blue Shield, we just got rid of them because they wanted to raise our premiums 32%. That’s a $252 increase PER MONTH for a grand total of $1052. That’s more than my mortgage!!!

    If there’s not a profit margin in there somewhere, then somebody is skimming some serious cash off the top.

  6. Erica said:

    There are lots of issues with America switching to Universal Health Care, and these problems need to be addressed before we jump into single payer health care.

    My personal view on it is that few things really matters if we are not healthy. Sure we can spend tax dollars to fix the roads, pay for education, or build up an army, but does that really matter to the person that is laying in bed dying because he can’t get the care he needs in America? Probably not-

    If you are interested (and a mom) come and join Moms for Universal Health Care at cafemom.com. I try to post both sides of the issue so that you can make a well informed choice on UHC.



Leave a Comment




Brighter Planet's 350 Challenge



The 2008 Mothers Acting Up
Handbook is now available!


Safer Toy Guide 2007




Copyright 2007 • Moms Speak Up • All Rights Reserved